Skip to content
StrikeOps

AD CS Web Enrollment NTLM Relay (ESC8)

CriticalTypical severity Active DirectoryCWE-294ATT&CK T1649

01Description

Active Directory Certificate Services web enrollment endpoints accepted NTLM authentication over HTTP without Extended Protection for Authentication (EPA).

02Impact

An attacker can coerce a domain controller to authenticate and relay that authentication to the web enrollment endpoint, obtaining a certificate for the domain controller and compromising the domain.

03Severity

Typically

Critical

Typically Critical. Critical where coercion of a domain controller is possible, as relaying its authentication to web enrollment yields a certificate for the domain controller.

04How to verify

  1. 1Identify AD CS web enrollment and certificate enrollment web service endpoints.
  2. 2Check whether HTTP is allowed, NTLM accepted and EPA disabled, for example with Certipy.
  3. 3Where authorized, demonstrate relay using a designated test machine rather than a production domain controller.

Testing note: only test systems you are authorized to test, within the agreed scope and rules of engagement. Verification steps are written for professional testers and avoid destructive techniques.

05Remediation

  1. 1Disable web enrollment if not required.
  2. 2Otherwise require HTTPS and enable Extended Protection for Authentication, and disable NTLM on the endpoints.
  3. 3Disable the Print Spooler and other coercion paths on domain controllers.

06References

Draft findings like this from your own evidence

Book a demo
Book a demo