01Description
An Active Directory Certificate Services (AD CS) certificate template was identified that allows enrollment by low-privileged users, permits client authentication, and allows the requester to supply the subject alternative name (the ENROLLEE_SUPPLIES_SUBJECT flag). This combination is known as ESC1.
02Impact
Any user who can enroll can request a certificate in the name of any other user, including a domain administrator, and use it to authenticate as that user. This provides a direct path from a standard domain account to full domain compromise.
03Severity
Typically
Critical
Typically Critical. Critical where low-privileged users can enroll, as it allows direct escalation to domain admin. High if enrollment is limited to a small privileged group.
04How to verify
- 1Enumerate certificate templates and their enrollment permissions, for example with Certipy (certipy find -vulnerable).
- 2Confirm the template allows client authentication and enrollee-supplied subject names.
- 3Where authorized, request a certificate for a designated test account to demonstrate the issue without impersonating real administrators.
Testing note: only test systems you are authorized to test, within the agreed scope and rules of engagement. Verification steps are written for professional testers and avoid destructive techniques.
05Remediation
- 1Remove the 'Supply in the request' subject name setting from the template, or require CA manager approval for issuance.
- 2Restrict enrollment rights to the specific groups that need the template.
- 3Audit all templates regularly with a tool such as Certipy or PSPKIAudit and monitor certificate issuance.
06References
Draft findings like this from your own evidence
Book a demo